Reformulation of Decision Execution and Honorary Council Position of Constitutional Court After Decision Number 604/G/2023/PTUN.JKT
Abstract
Abstract: This research analyzes the strength of the Decision of the Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court Number 2/MKMK/L/11/2023 and its execution after Decision Number 604/2023/PTUN.JKT questioning the Appointment of Constitutional Judge Suhartoyo in the object of a state administrative dispute in the form of Constitutional Court Decree Number 17 of 2013. This type of research is a doctrinal research that examines literature sources and statutory studies. Furthermore, this paper uses a conceptual approach and comparative approach that combines the concept of legal certainty and comparisons of several countries in terms of seeing a broader prototype of Ethics Institute arrangements comprehensively. After conducting an analysis, it can be concluded that the Decision of the Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court Number 17 of 2013 which contains ethical sanctions for violations of Constitutional Judge Anwar Usman is constrained by legal uncertainty in its execution. This is because there is no mechanism for the dismissal of the Chief Justice of the Constitutional Court after the imposition of ethical sanctions and there is a potential dualism in the ethical enforcement system that can be convoluted. The uncertainty of the execution of the Constitutional Court Honor Council Decision which has the potential to be convoluted with the involvement of the State Administrative Court in adjudicating the Decision a quo should be a reflection to distinguish the authority of law enforcement and ethical enforcement and their scope. This can be encouraged by strengthening the status of the Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court in its position as a Supervisory body as well as the arrangement of the Supreme Advisory Council in the Armenian Constitution.
Keywords: Honorary Council of the Constitutional Court, Decision ethics, execution
References
Bedner , Adrian W. Study Socio -Legal (Denpasar: Library Larasan , 2012), 35.
Enrico Simanjuntak, State Administrative Court Procedure Law: Transformation & Reflection, (East Jakarta:
Sinar Grafika, 2018).
Lovett, Frank, A Republic of Law (Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press, 2016)
Otto, Jan Michiel, Legal Certainty in Developing Countries (Jakarta: National Law Commission of the Republic of
Indonesia, 2003).
Soerjono Soekanto and Sri Mamuji, Normative Legal Research - A Brief Review (Jakarta: Rajawali Press,
1985).
Yap Hage, Antonia Waltermann, and Bram Akkermans Introduction to Law (Cham: Springer
International Publishing, 2017).
Zaka Firma Aditya, Muhammad Adiguna Bimasakti, and Anna Erliyana, Hukum Administrasi
Negara Kontemporer: Konsep, Teori, dan Penerapannya di Indonesia (Depok: Rajawali Pers, 2023).
Journal
Blanc, Sandrine. "Deliberative Democracy and Corporate Constitutionalism: Considering Corporate
Constitutional Courts," Journal of Business Ethics, 188. 1 (2023), 1–15, https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-
022-05206-x
Hage, Jaap, Antonia Waltermann, and Bram Akkermans, eds., Introduction to Law (Cham: Springer International
Publishing, 2017), 54, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-57252-9
Hamm, Brandon, and Bryn S. Esplin, 'The Boundaries of “Good Behavior” and Judicial Competence:
Exploring Responsibilities and Authority Limitations of Cognitive Specialists in the Regulation of
Incapacitated Judges', Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 46. 2 (2018), 514–20,
https://doi.org/10.1177/1073110518782959
Hidayat, Agung, 'Critical Review of the Book "Legal Research" by Peter Mahmud Marzuki Legal Research Ad
Quem on Norms', YUSTISIA MERDEKA: Scientific Journal of Law, 7. 2 (2021), 117–25,
https://doi.org/10.33319/yume.v7i2.109
Ichsan, Moch., and Anang Dony Irawan, ' Moch. Ichsan and Anang Dony Irawan, "Kewenangan Mahkamah
Konstitusi Terhadap Putusan Perkara Nomor 90/Puu-XXI/2023." Gorontalo Law Review , 7. 1 (2024),
126, https://doi.org/10.32662/golrev.v7i1.3371
Jurdi, Fajlurrahman, Rizqa Ananda Hanapi, and Taufik Hidayat, Fajlurrahman Jurdi, Rizqa Ananda Hanapi,
And Taufik Hidayat, "Optimalisasi Fungsi Pengawasan Dewan Etik Mahkamah Konstitusi" Jurnal
Hukum & Pembangunan, 50. 3 (2021), 689, https://doi.org/10.21143/jhp.vol50.no3.2763
Jurisprudentie Journal, Volume 11 Issue 2, 2024 : 201-217
13
Khusnul Catur Prasetya and Moh Sa'diyin, ' Khusnul Catur Prasetya and Moh Sa’diyin, "Pelaksanaan
Pengawasan Terhadap Kode Etik Dan Perilaku Hakim Konstitusi Di Indonesia," JOSH: Journal of
Sharia , 3.02 (2024), 120–28, https://doi.org/10.55352/josh.v3i02.919
'Introducing Ethical Justice', Journal of Constitution and Democracy, 1. 1 (2021),
https://doi.org/10.7454/JKD.v1i1.1101
Simamora, Jonny, and Patricia Ekowati Suryaningsih, "Formation of the Membership of the Honorary
Council of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia as Ethical Trial Judges", 23. 1 (2024)
https://doi.org/10.33369/jik.v23i1.34330
Simons, Anton, ‘The Full and Empty Formula of Solovyov's Legal Philosophy: Juridical Pragmatism and
Ethical Perfectionism’, Archiv Für Rechts- Und Sozialphilosophie , 88. 4 (2002), 481–94
Sujono, Imam, 'The Urgency of Legal Discovery and the Use of Jurisprudence in the Authority of the
Constitutional Court', Constitutional Journal , 18.3 (2022), 585 https://doi.org/10.31078/jk1835
Van Hoecke, Mark, "Methodology of Comparative Legal Research," Law and Method , 2015
https://doi.org/10.5553/REM/.000010
Regulation
Republic of Indonesia, Law About Power Justice , Law Number 48 of 2009 , LN NO. 157 TLN NO. 5076
Republic Indonesia , Law About Court Constitution , Law Number 7 of 2020 Concerning Change Third On Constitution
Number 24 of 2003 Concerning Court Constitution , LN NO. 2016 TLN NO. 6554
Website
Ady Thea DA, ‘Sepanjang Sejarah MK, Tahun 2023 Paling Banyak Hakim Konstitusi Disanksi Etik’, 8
January 2024 < https://www. Hukumonline.com/berita/a/sepanjang-wisata-mk--tahun-2023-paling-besarhakim-konstitusi-disanksi-istik-lt659b6afc8159b/> accessed 29 April 2024
Lewis, Dan. "The Accidental Case for Loose Morals," August 2020 https://nowiknow.com/the-accidentalcase-for-loose-morals/ accessed on 11 October 2024
Prastiwi , Mahar . ""3 Pandangan Pakar Hukum Unair Tentang Putusan MK Terhadap Pilkada,"
Kompas . com . August 2024 available at :
https://www.kompas.com/edu/read/2024/08/24/154841871/3-pandangan-pakar-hukum-unairtentang-putusan-MK-terhadap-pilkada, accessed on September 21, 2024
Court of Constitution Republic of Indonesia, 'MK Forms PermanentMKMK ', Broadcast Press , December 2023
available at :
https://www.mkri.id/public/content/infoumum/press/pdf/press_3093_20.12.23%20MK%20BE
NTUK%20MKMK.pdf, accessed on : November 24, 2023
Poerana , Sigar Aji . Perbedaan Sifat Putusan Deklarator, Konstitutif, Dan Kondemnator,",
Hukumonline.Com , November 19, 202, available at :
https://www.hukumonline.com/klinik/a/perbedaan-sifat-putusan-deklarator--konstitutif--dankondemnator-lt58ed9048160ee /, accessed on September 12, 2024
Mantalean , Vitorio and Dani Prabowo. " Terungkap Isi Gugatan Ke PTUN, Anwar Usman Ingin
Kembali Jadi Ketua MK," January 31, 2024,
https://nasional.kompas.com/read/2024/01/31/16313461/terungkap-isi-gugatan-ke-ptun-anwarusman-ingin-kembali-jadi-ketua-mk?page=alln, accessed on : September 24, 2024
Copyright (c) 2024 Alif wili utama, Anna Erliyana
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Once an article was published in the journal, the author(s) are:
- to retain copyright and grant to the journal right licensed under Creative Commons License Attribution that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship.
- permitted to publish their work online in third parties as it can lead wider dissemination of the work, with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal
- continue to be the copyright owner and allow the journal to publish the article with the CC BY-NC-SA license
- receiving a DOI (Digital Object Identifier) of the work.
